Home       About Us       Campaigns       Releases       Links       Contact Us       Take Action
Background
What's Wrong With Full Wards?
Why Not Now?
Why Only Some Changes Now?
Why Only Three Systems?
1996 Election?
1999 Election?

Factsheets
What is Pro Rep?
Why PR?
PR in Action
Myths About PR
New Zealand Model

Take Action
Hearing Dates
Submission Details
Join Us
Announcements Lists
Discussion Lists

Contact Us
fev@alternatives.com   

 

  Welcome to Fair Elections Vancouver

Fair Elections Vancouver assisted the Know Wards Coalition in successfully defeating an October 16, 2004, city wide referendum that would have changed the way Vancouver elected it's City Council. That referendum was between the current at-large system and a ward system.

The ward system proposed comprised exclusively of councillors elected from first-past-the-post single member wards and was the same non-proportional electoral district system used at the provincial and federal levels. That system is a winner take all system that suffers from unbalanced -- and sometimes wildly unbalanced -- election results, a sense of wasted votes, and "vote splitting" where there are more than two parties or candidates. This type of system experiences lower voter turnout and more non-participation when compared to other voting systems that incorporate proportionality (proportional representation) or preferential voting (ranked ballots).

A voting system should be measured on these principles:

  1. Proportionality: there should be a close correspondence between the percentage of votes a party or political affiliation wins and the percentage of seats it wins.
     
  2. Voter Choice: comparatively you want a voting system that is better at presenting the choices that voters want, and encourages voters to vote sincerely, rather than strategically.
     
  3. Local Representation: all regions in Vancouver should be fairly represented in City Council.
     
  4. Every Vote Counts: the voting system should accord equal weight to all ballots cast and should minimize the wastage of votes.

We feel there are better systems than the at-large system we have now and a first-past-the-post ward system. If you agree,

Implementing a voting system that is not better than the one we have now would be a big mistake and a waste of taxpayers money. Local democracy advocates did not call on the Berger Commission to implement any of the first-past-the-post electoral systems that commission only considered.